This is a series about … well, series. I do so love stories that continue across volumes, in whatever form: linked short stories, novels, novellas, television, movies. I’ve already got a list of series I’ve recently read, re-read, watched, or re-watched that I plan to blog about. I might even, down the line, open myself up to letting other people suggest titles I should read/watch and then blog about.
We all have That Thing (or sometimes, Those Things) that friends have been recommending for months/years/decades that we just, for one reason or another, put off reading/watching/experiencing. For me, the reason is often, but not always, that I’m afraid I will not like That Thing as much as my friends did and thus will disappoint the friends – which would bother me far more than being disappointed in That Thing myself. But sometimes, it’s just because That Thing isn’t available in a format I can experience it in.
For most of a decade now, my friends Dave and Jim have been extolling the virtues of a short-lived television series called Terriers. And for most of that time, it’s been difficult to find given that it’s never been released on DVD and I didn’t really have access to any streaming services that it may or may not have been on. But Dave recently discovered the show is available on Hulu, informed Jim and myself, and well… there really was no reason not to watch it, since I have Hulu (even if I rarely use it).
For those unfamiliar with it, Terriers ran on FX for one 13-episode season back in 2010. It starred Donal Logue as Hank Dolworth, recovering alcoholic ex-cop, and Michael Raymond-James as Britt Pollack, former break-and-enter-man, who share an unlicensed private eye business in Ocean Beach, CA. The main cast was rounded out by Kimberly Quinn as Hank’s ex-wife Gretchen Seiter; Laura Allen as Britt’s live-in girlfriend Katie Nichols; Jamie Denbo as the boys’ lawyer/employer Maggie Lefferts; and Rockmond Dunbar as Hank’s former police partner Detective Mark Gustafson, plus frequent guest stars Loren Dean as Gretchen’s fiancée Jason and Karina Logue as Hank’s sister Stephanie. Folks, this is one of the tightest casts I’ve seen on a television series. They all have great chemistry; there’s not a single relationship (romantic, platonic, familial, or business) that isn’t completely believable. Even the single-episode guest stars have the right level of timing and rapport with the regulars (especially D.J.”Shangela” Pierce in the “Pimp Daddy” episode – one of those one-off characters I suspect we’d have seen more of had the series been renewed – and Noel Fisher in “Missing Persons”).
Of course, it helps that the cast actually has strong material to work with. The dialogue is sharp: witty, biting, deeply emotional one moment and tension-breaking the next. And while the main characters share a sense of humor, they don’t speak alike at all. This is one of those rare shows where the writers understand their characters well enough to not put the wrong words, the wrong turns of phrase, into their mouths. The season arc, mini-arcs and single-episode plots all weave together almost perfectly. Small seeds in early episodes pay off in big ways down the line (examples that aren’t too spoilery: a throw-away line in the pilot in which Hank jokes that he’s possibly going senile because he doesn’t remember putting dishes away leads to a great reveal a few episodes later; Britt’s casual willingness to at least threaten violence to get information in the early episodes of course creates problems later on). If I went back and watched with greater scrutiny, I would not be surprised to find a lot of small moments of dialogue or visuals that hint at things to come. Very often, the “case of the week” mirrors themes of the overall arc or features smaller character moments that play into the whole. And the show is yet another example of why Short Seasons work so well: with only thirteen episodes, there’s less chance of a “filler” episode causing the viewer to lose interest or contradictory details sneaking in to derail the viewer with “wait, didn’t they say something completely different last episode” thoughts. You’re more likely to be derailed by “wait, that’s what he meant when he said X” or “holy shit, did they set that up four episodes ago? I think they did” thoughts. The season arc that starts in the pilot (looking for a friend’s daughter, Hank and Britt stumble on a much larger real estate mystery) is concluded in the season/series finale (which also, sort of subtly, sets up who the “big bad” for the start of season two would have been). But not every episode features the season arc up-front. There are several episodes in the middle where the case of the week is the central concern and the season-arc is either barely mentioned or moves along incrementally, and those episodes work to relieve tension for the characters and the viewers (the aforementioned “Missing Persons” and “Pimp Daddy” are excellent examples). The mini-arcs (Hank’s sister’s mental illness; Gretchen’s impending re-marriage; Britt and Katie’s relationship speed-bumps) are spaced out well and feed each other. There’s never a sense that too much is going on, never a sense that any particular storyline isn’t getting the room it needs. If anything, my one complaint/regret is that Maggie Lefferts and Mark Gustavson, while fully-realized characters played solidly by their respective actors, are more clearly around to Move Plot Along or Create Complications. I hope that, had the series gone to season two, they would have been given mini-arcs of their own.
Tonally, Terriers is absolutely modern noir. The setting may be the sunny San Diego area and the clothes may be lightweight and warm-weather appropriate, but Hank and Britt could just as easily be operating out of 1930s Los Angeles. They’re the main characters, they’re the “nice guys,” but they walk a very morally grey line throughout the series. Like the best noir detectives, they’re our protagonists but they’re not always good guys. Hank may have a handle on his alcoholism, but he’s impulsive to a fault, his recklessness making situations worse more often than fixing them. Britt may be happy-go-lucky but he’s got a dark streak that rears up at the worst times. They have blind-spots where their families and friends are concerned. They want Justice to prevail, but they’re often willing to cut corners to make it happen. They’re all heart, but they’re also downtrodden: Hank’s truck looks like it could stop working at any moment, and Britt’s motorcycle doesn’t look much better. Money is always an issue for both of them, and creates numerous complications. Still, you can’t help but root for them. Their hearts are in the right place even if their methods are sometimes a little suspect. And man, are they both charming.
Terriers ultimately didn’t get picked up for a second season, which is a shame. Friends Dave and Jim theorize that had the show debuted just a couple of years later, in the midst of Peak TV, it might have made it at least through season two if not three. But would it have been the same creature if it was picked up a few years later? Would it even have had the same cast? By 2014, Donal Logue had moved on to starring in the proto-Batman series Gotham, while Michael Raymond-James was appearing somewhat regularly on fairy-tales-in-the-real-world series Once Upon A Time. No, I think it’s preferable that Terriers was produced when it was, with the cast it had. I’m hard pressed to think of anyone else at all playing Hank and Britt with such chemistry. I also wouldn’t be adverse, since reunions are all the rage, for another 10-13 episode run taking place now and showing us where the guys and gals have ended up, provided the writing is as complex and sharp as we’d expect.