Sometimes, you need a little spectacle. Back to the Future: The Musical provides it, in great heaping doses.
I feel like the Winter Garden Theater usually goes out of its’ way to make the house feel like part of the set/show. For BttF:TM, they’ve rigged flashing computer circuits from the stage out along the box seats and across the ceiling to at least midway above the orchestra seats to keep you in mind of a mad scientist’s crazy plan. (If you’re sitting along the outer edges of the orchestra, as we were, this makes reading the Playbill before the show exceedingly difficult, but it definitely sets a mood.) The front scrim (instead of a curtain) shows the show’s logo when it isn’t reminding you that photography during the show is prohibited because it would mess with the space-time continuum (pretty cute).
The staging is heavy reliant on special effects (the front scrim and back display do a lot of the heavy lifting on that score) both for the time travel scenes (including Doc’s number, “21st Century,” that opens Act Two) and for just moving around town or even around the school. The car, of course, is the big draw and it looks and sounds great (the car even gets a bit of KITT-like personality, although I scoured the Playbill and could not find out who voices her).
Casey Likes is a likeable Marty McFly. He’s got a great singing voice and sells both the ballads (his “Got No Future” was particularly moving) and the rock numbers (“The Power of Love” and “Back in Time”). But if I’m being totally honest – his dialogue often sounded like he was trying too hard to be Michael J. Fox. Which, okay, that’s not a horrible thing, but I would have liked to see Likes make the part more his own.
Which is what Roger Bart did with Doc Brown. There was little of Christopher Lloyd’s mannerisms or inflections in Bart’s performance, and I absolutely loved it. He was just as “over the top” as Lloyd, but in a vastly different way, and was clearly enjoying every moment he was on stage. He also knew exactly when to tone it down. I will go on record here that Bart’s Act Two ballad, “For the Dreamers,” made me tear up and is hands-down my favorite original song in the show.
The chemistry between Likes and Bart is palpable. They’re a great pair, all of their scenes together crackle. I may be mistaken, but I think there are a few moments where they improvise, and there was one moment where they both broke slightly. It was as much fun to watch their scenes together as it was as a kid to watch Harvey Korman and Tim Conway crack each other up on the Carol Burnett Show.
We had understudy Becca Petersen as Lorraine Baines McFly, alongside Evan Alexander Smith as George, and they were both fantastic. Petersen played the difference between 1985 alcoholic bitter Lorraine and 1955 romantic lusty Lorraine wonderfully; Smith doesn’t get to show that same type of character change until the final scenes but his nerdy, anxious, underdog George is someone you can’t help but feel sorry for and want to see succeed (something I don’t think I ever really got from Crispin Glover in the movie). I totally believed Lorraine falling for George after he punches Biff and when he shows himself to be a gentleman at the dance.
I feel a little bad for Nathaniel Hackmann, as Biff is not really given a chance to be anything beyond the stereotypical villain. He does have a solid “villain song” in Act Two (“Teach Him a Lesson”), and physically he looks more like Thomas F. Wilson than any of the other actors look like their movie counterparts. I’m not saying bully Biff should have been given any kind of tragic backstory (as we see with so many classic villains who get their own movies these days), but I wonder if the show couldn’t have added a little more depth or at least given Hackmann a bit more variation to play.
A great surprise in the show was understudy Kevin Curtis as Goldie Wilson. His “Gotta Start Somewhere” was the showstopper of Act One, with at least a full minute of applause. I love it when a supporting character gets a spotlight moment and delivers on it. Curtis has an incredibly voice; I hope wonderful things are in his future.
There are some parts of the film that just couldn’t be adapted to stage, even with the incredible special effects. So the skateboard-and-car chase of the film (that ends with Biff and his cronies covered in manure) is replaced here with a foot chase through the school, full of slapstick pratfalls, all while Lorraine sings “Something About That Boy.” It’s a strong end-of-Act-One full cast number, although nowhere near as funny as the movie chase.
Ultimately, Back to the Future: The Musical is exactly what it claims to be: feel good fun for the whole family, special effects and sound effects heavy, with a couple of original songs that might stick in your head (alongside classics by Chuck Berry (“Johnny B. Goode”) and Huey Lewis (The Power of Love” and “Back in Time”) that are required when adapting Back to the Future). It doesn’t pretend to be anything else. Go in with the expectation that you’re just going to have fun, and you won’t be disappointed.
I’ve always loved live theater, and in the past couple of years I’ve been making a stronger effort to see more of it. Theater Thursday is a new occasionally series where I talk about live theater, both shows I’ve seen recently and shows I’ve loved in the past.