I love watching gymnasts and acrobats do their thing. I love creative puppetry. I enjoy tightly harmonized folk-pop music. And I’m partial to stories about the circus/carnivals. So Water for Elephants piqued my interest when it was announced, even before I found out that Grant Gustin, my second-favorite television Flash (sorry, Grant fans, John Wesley Shipp will always have the number one spot there … but that’s a post for another time), would be making his Broadway debut in the lead role. My goddaughter also wanted to see it, so off we went to the Imperial Theatre a week or so before the 2024 Tony Awards.
Based on the novel of the same name by Sara Gruen, which my office book club read shortly after it came out, with book by Rick Elice and music and lyrics by Pigpen Theatre Co., Water For Elephants is a memory play: elderly nursing home patient Jacob Jankowski attends a nearby traveling circus and regals the staff with his own tale of joining Benzini Brothers’ Most Spectacular Circus during the Prohibition years. Jacob becomes the circus’s veterinarian and falls for Marlena, the horse trainer, running him afoul of the owner/ringmaster (and Marlena’s abusive husband), August, and his trusted assistant Wade.
The gymnastics/acrobatics in this show are stunning: pole work, ringwork, aerial silks, tumbling, death-drops, trapeze … and probably a dozen other moves I don’t know the names for but love watching. Most of the full ensemble numbers, from “The Road Don’t Make You Young” to the act one closer “The Grand Spec,” from “Zostan” at the start of act two to the various show-ending reprises, feature multiple gymnastic/acrobatic components happening concurrently. Many of these are also performed at top speed. The cast must be exhausted by intermission and burnt out by the end of the show. (I can’t imagine what a two-show day feels like). The seamlessness in which all of them interweave without collisions, without missing timing … it really blew me away. Of particular note: the aerial silk work of Antoine Boissereau during “Easy” is so stunning it brought me to tears (okay, the lyrics, sung beautifully by Isabelle McCalla as Marlena, also helped the tears to flow).
The animal costuming/puppetry work is also wonderful. Since the setting is a circus, the animals have to be represented somehow. Puppet designers Ray Wetmore, JR Goodman, and Camille Labarre, alongside costume designer David Israel Reynoso, went in a different direction from that other long-running Broadway show where humans play animals (The Lion King). Rather than fully-articulated and detailed puppet costumes, they went for broad details that imply – allowing the actors playing those animals to have greater range of movement, which benefitted the show greatly, especially in the climactic stampede scene.
Speaking of that scene – Bradley King’s lighting design is great throughout the show but spectacular in that specific moment. Combined with the way the scene is staged and the cacophonous music, the lighting puts the audience as close to being in that stampede as you can be without leaving your seat.
I’ve given praise to the ensemble’s athleticism. Now, the leads: Gregg Edelman (who I will see in just about anything) is heartbreaking and loveable as the lonely, wistful elderly Jacob. He is counterpointed by Grant Gustin’s earnest performance as the youthful, also lonely and heartbreaking, somewhat naïve younger Jacob. As mentioned, Isabella McCalla is Marlena; her voice is sweet, soaring, and beautiful. Paul Alexander Nolan’s brutish/conniving/charismatic turn as August might have been my favorite villain turn of the season so far.
The supporting cast were equally enjoyable: Stan Brown’s Camel, the man who takes younger Jacob under his wing, is heartwarming and heartbreaking at the same time; Joe De Paul’s Walter, the circus clown/comedian, is just hysterical; Sara Gettelfinger steals every scene she’s in as Barbara, who runs the “exotic dancer” sideshow, with a wonderful acerbic wit. And as Wade, August’s right-hand-man-without-a-conscience, Wade McCollum made the part more than just a one-note sidekick.
Pigpen Theater Co’s music is period-appropriate, a nice blend of ballads and folk/pop with lyrics that are emotive and build on character. In the moment, pretty much every song hits the right spot, whether that be infectious joy or deep loss. I must admit, though: after the show was over, I had a hard time calling any particular song to mind. I usually leave a musical humming/trying to remember the lyrics of at least one song. Your experience may be different, of course.
Despite that one little (very personal, not true for everyone) complaint, I would say that if you love the circus, acrobatics, puppetry, and strong vocal performances … see Water for Elephants. I know that as I post this, Grant Gustin is nearing his final performance and Joe De Paul has already left, but don’t let that stop you.
I’ve always loved live theater, and in the past couple of years I’ve been making a stronger effort to see more of it. Theater Thursday is a new occasionally series where I talk about live theater, both shows I’ve seen recently and shows I’ve loved in the past.